Julie Harris

~ as ~

Sister Anthony

Andrew McCarthy

~ as ~

Richard Reilly

Trini Alvarado

~ as ~

Beth

Jessica Hecht

~ as ~

Sister Mary

Shannon Holt

~ as ~

Sister Lucia 1939

Betty Aberlin

~ as ~

Sister Sarah

Anne Pitoniak

~ as ~

Mother Superior Francis

Imogene Bliss

~ as ~

Sister Lucia 1996

Nili Bassman

~ as ~

Anna 1950

Lulee Fisher

~ as ~

Sister Rose