Molly C. Quinn

~ as ~

Sister Mary

Jake Horowitz

~ as ~

Benjamin

Hayley McFarland

~ as ~

Sister Agnes

Rachel True

~ as ~

Sister Ruth

Zandy Hartig

~ as ~

Sister Honey

Chris Browning

~ as ~

Father Black

Ben Hall

~ as ~

Father Donaghue

Mary Buss

~ as ~

Mother Superior

Chris Sullivan

~ as ~

Curly

Sean Gunn

~ as ~

Paul Satchimo