Ally Sheedy

~ as ~

Jane

Sean Patrick Flanery

~ as ~

Tom O'Donnell

Meat Loaf

~ as ~

Detective Jack Morris (as Meat Loaf Aday)

Patty McCormack

~ as ~

Aunt Gertrude

Nia Peeples

~ as ~

Evelyn

Valerie Landsburg

~ as ~

Sheryl Jackman

Frank Pesce

~ as ~

Virgil Jackman

Rico Simonini

~ as ~

Joel Markham

Andrew Patrick Ralston

~ as ~

District Attorney Adam McArthur

Al Rodrigo

~ as ~

Jim Rhode