Lacey Chabert

~ as ~

Tess Harper

Brennan Elliott

~ as ~

Logan O'Connor

Barbara Niven

~ as ~

Aunt Candace

John Kapelos

~ as ~

Chief Chauncey O'Connor

Romaine Waite

~ as ~

Winston Sams

Lara Jean Chorostecki

~ as ~

Christina Blake

Alex Paxton-Beesley

~ as ~

Abby Miller

Kimberly J. Brown

~ as ~

Angela

Kyle Buchanan

~ as ~

Lyle Clark

Lindsay Owen Pierre

~ as ~

Emory Nelson