Rachel Bloom

~ as ~

Rebecca Bunch

Donna Lynne Champlin

~ as ~

Paula Proctor

Vincent Rodriguez III

~ as ~

Josh Chan

Pete Gardner

~ as ~

Darryl Whitefeather

Vella Lovell

~ as ~

Heather Davis

Gabrielle Ruiz

~ as ~

Valencia Perez

Scott Michael Foster

~ as ~

Nathaniel

Santino Fontana

~ as ~

Greg Serrano

David Hull

~ as ~

White Josh

Steele Stebbins

~ as ~

Tommy Proctor