Neil Patrick Harris

~ as ~

William Coit

Bonnie Bedelia

~ as ~

Jill Coit

Meredith Salenger

~ as ~

Robin Coit

Terry Kiser

~ as ~

Uncle Paul

Jon Pennell

~ as ~

Seth Coit

Gary Graham

~ as ~

Mike Backus

Ernie Lively

~ as ~

Gerry Boggs

Arthur Taxier

~ as ~

Rev. Charles Coit

Steven Williams

~ as ~

Det. Sexton

Michael MacRae

~ as ~

Carl Steely