Gary Cooper

~ as ~

Wild Bill Hickok

Jean Arthur

~ as ~

Calamity Jane

James Ellison

~ as ~

William "Buffalo Bill" Cody

Charles Bickford

~ as ~

John Lattimer

Helen Burgess

~ as ~

Louisa Cody

Porter Hall

~ as ~

Jack McCall

Paul Harvey

~ as ~

Yellow Hand

Victor Varconi

~ as ~

Painted Horse

John Miljan

~ as ~

General George A. Custer

Frank McGlynn Sr.

~ as ~

Abraham Lincoln