Jack Antonoff

~ as ~

Rick Antonoff

Gillian Jacobs

~ as ~

Shira Wall

Mae Whitman

~ as ~

Hobbit / Friend / Pip #1

Jenny Slate

~ as ~

Friend / Pumpkin Salesperson / Gynecologist

Caroline Ellis

~ as ~

Friend / Pip #2

Rachel Antonoff

~ as ~

Friend

Nattie Harold

~ as ~

Friend

Miles Heizer

~ as ~

Friend

Andrew Dost

~ as ~

Friend / Greasy Ed

Derek Waters

~ as ~

Friend