Leif Erickson

~ as ~

Pilate

Nelson Leigh

~ as ~

Joseph of Arimathea

Ruth Hussey

~ as ~

Mary

Henry Brandon

~ as ~

Cassius

James Dean

~ as ~

John

Jeanne Cagney

~ as ~

Mary Magdalene

Joan Leslie

~ as ~

Claudia

Gordon Oliver

~ as ~

Padre

Roddy McDowall

~ as ~

Pvt. Huntington (The Professor)

Gene Lockhart

~ as ~

Matthew