Jason Ritter

~ as ~

Jeff

Emmanuelle Chriqui

~ as ~

Marla

James Brolin

~ as ~

Ed

Christine Lahti

~ as ~

Sherry

Kate Corbett

~ as ~

Tammy

Rainbow Sun Francks

~ as ~

Dean

Naomi Snieckus

~ as ~

Ellen

Steven McCarthy

~ as ~

Keith

Vinay Virmani

~ as ~

Sam

Jim Calarco

~ as ~

Police officer