Beck Bennett

~ as ~

Christopher

Britt Lower

~ as ~

Rachael

Jessy Hodges

~ as ~

Melissa

Conan O'Brien

~ as ~

Craig

Scott Bowser

~ as ~

Employee

Kirby Howell-Baptiste

~ as ~

Employee

Willy Roberts

~ as ~

Employee

Darrell Snedeger

~ as ~

New Boyfriend

Lazarus Guidry

~ as ~

Vinny

Ed Ferrara

~ as ~

Max