James Cagney

~ as ~

New York Police Commissioner Rhinelander Waldo

Brad Dourif

~ as ~

Younger Brother

Moses Gunn

~ as ~

Booker T. Washington

Elizabeth McGovern

~ as ~

Evelyn Nesbit

Kenneth McMillan

~ as ~

Willie Conklin

Pat O’Brien

~ as ~

Delmas

Donald O'Connor

~ as ~

Evelyn's Dance Instructor

James Olson

~ as ~

Father

Mandy Patinkin

~ as ~

Tateh

Howard Rollins

~ as ~

Coalhouse Walker Jr.