Jack Scalia

~ as ~

Joseph 'Joey' Buttafuoco

Alyssa Milano

~ as ~

Amy Fisher

Phyllis Lyons

~ as ~

Mary Jo Buttafuoco

Leo Rossi

~ as ~

Bobby Buttafuoco

J.E. Freeman

~ as ~

Det. Marty Algar

Peter Van Norden

~ as ~

Joey's Attorney

Lawrence Tierney

~ as ~

Joey Buttafucco's Father

Anne DeSalvo

~ as ~

Roseann Fisher

Michael Bowen

~ as ~

Paul Makely

Jack Kehler

~ as ~

Elliot Fisher