Betty Gilpin

~ as ~

Elizabeth Abbott / Sister Simone

Jake McDorman

~ as ~

Preston Wiley

Andy McQueen

~ as ~

Jay

Chris Diamantopoulos

~ as ~

JQ

Elizabeth Marvel

~ as ~

Celeste Abbott

Katja Herbers

~ as ~

Mathilde LaFleur

Tom Wlaschiha

~ as ~

Father Hans Ziegler

Ely Henry

~ as ~

JPV

Jack Foley

~ as ~

Nerd with a Beard

Ben Chaplin

~ as ~

Arthur Schrödinger