Richard Egan

~ as ~

Ken Jorgenson

Dorothy McGuire

~ as ~

Sylvia Hunter

Sandra Dee

~ as ~

Molly Jorgenson

Arthur Kennedy

~ as ~

Bart Hunter

Troy Donahue

~ as ~

Johnny Hunter

Beulah Bondi

~ as ~

Mrs. Emily Hamilton Hamble

Constance Ford

~ as ~

Helen Jorgenson

Jack Richardson

~ as ~

Claude Andrews

Martin Eric

~ as ~

Todd Harper, Handyman at Pine Island Inn

Eleanor Audley

~ as ~

Waiting Guest at Molly's College (uncredited)