John Lund

~ as ~

Lance Horton

Brian Donlevy

~ as ~

Charles Quantrill

Audrey Totter

~ as ~

Kate Quantrill / Kitty McCoy

Joan Leslie

~ as ~

Sally Maris

Ben Cooper

~ as ~

Jesse James

James Brown

~ as ~

Frank James

Nina Varela

~ as ~

Mayor Delilah Courtney

Ellen Corby

~ as ~

First Townswoman

Fern Hall

~ as ~

Second Woman

Minerva Urecal

~ as ~

Mrs. Stuart