Fredric March

~ as ~

Christopher Columbus

Florence Eldridge

~ as ~

Queen Isabella

Francis L. Sullivan

~ as ~

Francisco de Bobadilla

Kathleen Ryan

~ as ~

Beatriz Enriquez de Arana

Derek Bond

~ as ~

Diego de Arana

Nora Swinburne

~ as ~

Joanna de Torres

Abraham Sofaer

~ as ~

Luis de Santangel

Linden Travers

~ as ~

Beatriz de Peraza

James Robertson Justice

~ as ~

Martin Alonso Pinzon

Dennis Vance

~ as ~

Francisco Pinzon