Elizabeth Montgomery

~ as ~

Lizzie Borden

Fionnula Flanagan

~ as ~

Bridget Sullivan

Ed Flanders

~ as ~

Hosea Knowlton

Katherine Helmond

~ as ~

Emma Borden

Don Porter

~ as ~

George Robinson

Fritz Weaver

~ as ~

Mr. Andrew Borden

Bonnie Bartlett

~ as ~

Sylvia Knowlton

Helen Craig

~ as ~

Mrs. Abby Borden

Hayden Rorke

~ as ~

Julien Ralph

Gloria Stuart

~ as ~

Store customer